Dear Santa, I'd Rather Be on Fishers Island
The Ultimate Fishers Island Gift Guide.
We've rounded up a few island favourites to make your Christmas shopping a little easier.
Shop local, support our island businesses and give a little piece of Fishers this Christmas!
FICC Vintage Ski Beanie - $30 at FICC
A little après-ski, a lot of Fishers Island! Keep cosy this winter with our limited-edition vintage ski-inspired beanies. Available Exclusively at the FICC office.
The Classic Backgammon Board - $100 at FICC
A little island travel favourite! Available online here or in person at the FICC.
https://gammn.com/?srsltid=AYCX9vJoCzGb1mzX0cFbgDHq7pGqi69muhv3NNwr2-vVd-m94JSGi46V
Fishers Island Cookbook - $10 at FICC
A taste of Fishers Island, wherever you are! The perfect gift for anyone who loves cooking, island traditions and has little nostalgia for Pandemic activities.
Bowling Alley Hire at FICC $60 per hour per lane
Give the gift of a good time! Treat family or friends to an hour on our vintage bowling lanes. A friendly little competition never hurt anyone!
Reiki with Stacey - $
Give someone the gift of relaxation this Christmas. A Reiki session with Stacey is a thoughtful way to encourage a little rest and self-care.
Pet Pampering with Stacy Hoch
Don't forget your four-legged islanders! Treat a beloved pet to a little extra TLC with Stacy Hoch.
A Loaded West End Gift Card for Summer 2027
Give them something to look forward to! A gift card ready to spend when summer rolls around again. Future island memories, sorted.
Fishers Island Lemonade
A little taste of summer in the middle of winter! A Fishers Island favourite for anyone dreaming of sunshine and beach days.
Something Special from The Beach Plum
For the island lover who has everything (almost!). Browse The Beach Plum for a thoughtful gift with a little Fishers Island charm.
Coffee from Island Hardware
For the person who takes their morning coffee seriously. A little island comfort to brighten up those chilly winter mornings.
Buy a Brick, Leave a Legacy – available online here
A gift that lasts for generations! Dedicate an engraved brick to family, friends or someone special, and become a permanent part of the Fishers Island Community Center.
Something from Johnnio
Gift idea to be confirmed. A chance to highlight a favourite local product or service.
Fishers Island Village Market Spices – stocking stuffers $6.
Gift idea to be confirmed. Pick out a local favourite, a practical stocking stuffer or something uniquely Fishers Island.